Skip to main content

_

Notes from Underground

  And, indeed, I will ask on my own account here, an idle question: which is better—cheap happiness or exalted sufferings? Well, which is better?---Fyodor Dostoevsky ---Notes from Underground Fyodor Dostoevsky ---Notes from Underground Even now, so many years later, all this is somehow a very evil memory. I have many evil memories now, but ... hadn’t I better end my “Notes” here? I believe I made a mistake in beginning to write them, anyway I have felt ashamed all the time I’ve been writing this story; so it’s hardly literature so much as a corrective punishment.  Why, to tell long stories, showing how I have spoiled my life through morally rotting in my corner, through lack of fitting environment, through divorce from real life, and rankling spite in my underground world, would certainly not be interesting; a novel needs a hero, and all the traits for an anti-hero are expressly gathered together here, and what matters most, it all produces an unpleasant impression, for we are...

Hope

To be human is to be a miracle of evolution conscious of its own miraculousness — a consciousness beautiful and bittersweet, for we have paid for it with a parallel awareness not only of our fundamental improbability but of our staggering fragility, of how physiologically precarious our survival is and how psychologically vulnerable our sanity. To make that awareness bearable, we have evolved a singular faculty that might just be the crowning miracle of our consciousness: hope.-- Erich Fromm


The Marriage of Maria Braun (1979)




 Die Ehe der Maria Braun

Rainer Werner Fassbinder's 1979 masterpiece is more than a melodrama; it is a clinical dissection of the Wirtschaftswunder—the West German Economic Miracle—through the eyes of a woman who trades her heart for a nation's recovery. 

Bombs fell as Maria was married to a soldier named Hermann Braun, with the wedding party scrambling for safety. Then came more years of the war. Whatever happened to Maria Braun during those years created a woman who is strong and cruel, sad and indomitable. She is so loyal to her husband of less than a day that she kills for him, and so pitiless to her lover of many years that she drives him to death.

 

"The Marriage of Maria Braun" was made by Rainer Werner Fassbinder in 1979, near the end of a career so short and dazzling that it still seems incredible he did so much and died so young. Fassbinder made at least 30 features, or many more if you count his television productions, including the 15-hour miniseries "Berlin Alexanderplatz," and he did it all between 1969 and his death at age 37 in 1982.

Fassbinder's world was one in which sex, ego and money drove his characters to cruelty, sadism and self-destruction. It is never difficult to discover what they want, or puzzling to see how they go about it. The suggestion is that the war years and the postwar years wounded the German psyche so profoundly that the survivors wanted what they wanted, now, on their terms. 

Fassbinder himself was cruel and distant to those around him, particularly those who loved him, and in Maria Braun, he created an indelible monster who is perversely fascinating because she knows exactly what she is doing and explains it to her victims while it is being done.




After the brief opening wedding scene, the story rejoins Maria and her mother immediately after World War II, when they are sharing a flat carved out of a bombed building. She believes her husband, Hermann (Klaus Lowitsch) is dead, although she haunts rail stations with his photograph. 
The population is starving and desperate; when an American GI tosses away a cigarette butt, a dozen Germans scramble for it. Maria applies for a job in a nightclub for American soldiers; it's located in a high school gym where she once attended school, and she mounts the parallel bars, which are still in place, and more or less orders the owner to give her the job.

The B-girl joint is the first step on Maria's relentless climb to success. We follow her from about 1946 to the mid-1950s. There is a black American soldier she is fond of (they share the movie's only scene of physical affection), but when her husband unexpectedly returns and finds them in bed, she settles the matter by breaking a bottle over the GI's head. She did not plan to kill him, but he's dead. 
Her husband tells the court he did it and is sentenced to prison. Maria remains fiercely loyal to this absent spouse, who is essentially a stranger, for all the rest of the film; perhaps it is her form of loyalty to Germany in its defeat.

The gradual evolution of Maria Braun from a desperate scavenger to a rich beauty; Hanna Schygulla, who met Fassbinder in school and starred in 20 of his films, had an uncanny ability to float just out of range of analysis, as if she were not acting but getting her effects through dreamy murderous impulses -- that despite the fact that every shot was precisely blocked and the dialogue has the precision and brutality of a play by Neil LaBute.

What happens to Maria and her husband in the final scene was the subject of heated discussion after the film played at Cannes in May 1979. It's a surprise, but you must admit it is as plausible an ending as any other. I remember Fassbinder late at night at a back-street bar at Cannes that year, always in his black leather jacket, surrounded by his crowd, often scowling or arguing as they tried to please him. He was Maria Braun and they were all Oswalds. But he was a genius. That much everyone admitted.








ESSENTIAL RAINER WERNER FASSBINDER FILMS >>>







Rainer Werner Fassbinder was the engine room of post-war German film. In a career that lasted barely 15 years, he completed over 40 feature films, revolutionizing the way society looked at its own scars, prejudices, and hidden desires.

Influenced by the lush melodramas of Douglas Sirk and the alienation techniques of Bertolt Brecht, Fassbinder created a unique cinematic language. His films were not just movies; they were surgical dissections of power dynamics, exploitation, and the "exploitability of feelings."





A defining engine of the New German Cinema, Rainer Werner Fassbinder was one of the most astonishingly prolific auteurs in film history. Before his death at age 37 in 1982, he directed over 40 feature films, two massive television series, and dozens of plays—a relentless, chaotic output fueled by an obsession with exposing the psychological underbelly of post-war West Germany.

Core Thematic Obsessions

Fassbinder’s work is characterized by a brutal, deeply empathetic examination of power dynamics, operating on both macro-political and deeply intimate levels:

The Subversion of Melodrama: Heavily inspired by Hollywood director Douglas Sirk, Fassbinder hijacked the conventions of glossy soap operas to critique social structures. He used heightened emotional stakes to lay bare how society crushes outsiders, minorities, and the working class.

The Commodity of Love: In Fassbinder's cinematic universe, love is rarely pure; it is an economic transaction or a mechanism for power. His characters frequently exploit each other's vulnerabilities, proving that institutional oppression is often mirrored in private relationships.

The BRD Trilogy & Historical Amnesia: Through The Marriage of Maria Braun (1979), Veronika Voss (1982), and Lola (1981), he dissected the "Economic Miracle" of post-war West Germany, arguing that the nation’s rapid capitalist rebirth was built on a foundation of moral compromise and collective amnesia regarding its Nazi past.

Stylistic Signatures

The "Anti-Theater" Collective: Fassbinder worked with a recurring troupe of fiercely loyal (and frequently tormented) actors and collaborators, including Irm Hermann, Hanna Schygulla, Margit Carstensen, and cinematographer Michael Ballhaus.

Framing and Alienation: Influenced by Bertolt Brecht’s alienation effect, his visual style often isolates characters within the frame. Ballhaus and Fassbinder utilized mirrors, doorways, windows, and slow, tracking geometric camera movements to trap characters visually, emphasizing their social entrapment.

Essential Works


"Every decent director has only one subject and finally makes only the same film. My subject is the exploitability of feelings, whoever may be the one who exploits them." — Rainer Werner Fassbinder










The Marriage of Maria Braun (German: Die Ehe der Maria Braun) is a 1979 West German drama that stands as one of the most significant achievements of the New German Cinema movement. It is the first installment of Fassbinder’s BRD Trilogy (referring to the Bundesrepublik Deutschland), followed by Lola (1981) and Veronika Voss (1982).





Plot Summary

The film follows Maria Berger (Hanna Schygulla) and Hermann Braun (Klaus Löwitsch), who marry during an Allied bombing raid in 1943. After just "half a day and a whole night" together, Hermann is sent to the Eastern Front. At the war's end, Maria is informed that Hermann has died, but she remains steadfastly devoted to his memory.

To survive the post-war devastation, Maria works in a bar for American GIs, eventually beginning a relationship with Bill, a Black American soldier. When a very much alive Hermann unexpectedly returns from a POW camp and finds them in bed, a fight ensues. Maria kills Bill to protect Hermann, but Hermann takes the legal blame and goes to prison in her stead.

Maria then embarks on a ruthless ascent during the West German "Economic Miracle" (Wirtschaftswunder). She becomes the mistress and business partner of a wealthy industrialist, Karl Oswald, all while maintaining her loyalty to the imprisoned Hermann. The film culminates in an ambiguous explosion at the moment West Germany wins the 1954 World Cup, symbolizing the volatile reconciliation of Germany's past and its prosperous, but spiritually hollow, presen



Hanna Schygulla in her career-defining role

Hanna Schygulla’s portrayal of Maria Braun is widely considered one of the most mesmerizing, complex lead performances in European cinema. It fundamentally redefined her career, earned her the Silver Bear for Best Actress at the 1979 Berlin Film Festival, and established her internationally as the most electrifying German screen icon since Marlene Dietrich.

Interestingly, the role wasn't originally intended for her—Fassbinder had initially pursued Romy Schneider. However, Schygulla stepped in, marking her return to collaborating with Fassbinder after a multi-year hiatus, and completely made the film her own.
The Dialectic of Steel & Sentiment

What makes Schygulla’s performance so legendary is how she navigates the sharp, contradictory layers of Maria's psyche. She anchors the film's entire critique of capitalism by making Maria simultaneously chilling and deeply human.

The Steely Opportunist: Schygulla plays Maria with a calculated, aggressively confident pragmatism. When she seduces her way into the business world and transforms into a ruthless capitalist, she does so without an ounce of self-pity or hesitation. Schygulla gives Maria a distinctive, eyes-on-the-prize detachment—treating her own sexuality and emotional coldness as literal business assets to survive a broken system.

The Romantic Idealist: The tragic irony Schygulla captures is that Maria’s cold mercenary behavior is fueled by an absolute, almost delusional romantic devotion. She commits terrible acts and compromises her morality entirely for the sake of a husband she spent only "half a day and a long night" with. Critics often note that Schygulla brilliantly acts out a profound psychological mystery: Maria isn't infatuated with the actual man, but with the ideal of the marriage she has constructed in her head.
De Dietrich-esque Energy

Fassbinder and Schygulla actively channeled the ghost of classical Hollywood melodramas—specifically Josef von Sternberg's work with Marlene Dietrich—but subverted it for a post-war landscape.
Schygulla balances a mocking, self-aware sexuality with absolute desperation. She is emancipated and independent, yet bound entirely to her self-imposed romantic destiny. Her performance avoids the typical "femme fatale" or "rapacious woman" tropes; instead, she portrays a fiercely intelligent woman pulling herself out of physical and national ruins, only to find that her immense willpower has alienated her from her own humanity.

Ultimately, Schygulla doesn't ask the audience to easily love or hate Maria—she keeps the character mysterious, unpredictable, and strangely compelling from the opening air raid to the final, explosive frame.




The Final Scene: The Miracle of Bern

The film’s ending is one of the most debated in cinema history. As the radio broadcasts the final moments of the 1954 World Cup (where West Germany beat Hungary), Maria leaves the gas on in her kitchen. Whether the resulting explosion is an accident or a deliberate act of suicide remains ambiguous.

  • Symbolism: The explosion occurs exactly when Germany wins the Cup—the moment the "New Germany" is officially born on the world stage.

  • Interpretation: Some critics see it as the "bill coming due" for the moral shortcuts taken during the reconstruction. Others see it as Maria’s realization that the "Hermann" she loved no longer exists, leaving her with nothing but a hollowed-out success.





 He tormented his actors, threw drinks at his cameraman, and died of an overdose at 37, leaving behind two dead lovers – and an extraordinary body of work.



    1. Fassbinder directed his first feature in 1969, and was dead in 1982. Who else has created such a torrent of film, at such a high level of artistry? It's tempting to say he hurried because he knew his time was limited. Not at all. He hurried because his life was in his work, and those who knew him best wrote afterwards that he feared losing his friends and lovers if he did not always keep them around, in a flood of films and plays. If he had lived, and worked at the same rate, he would have made 80 films by now. Perhaps no one could have kept up that pace. He might have kept up the quality, however; it is sobering to think how much we lost when he died alone in that sad locked room.

    2. Fassbinder films capture a frantic life's desperation >>>