L'Enfant (The Child 2005) Skip to main content

_

Notes from Underground

  And, indeed, I will ask on my own account here, an idle question: which is better—cheap happiness or exalted sufferings? Well, which is better?---Fyodor Dostoevsky ---Notes from Underground Fyodor Dostoevsky ---Notes from Underground Even now, so many years later, all this is somehow a very evil memory. I have many evil memories now, but ... hadn’t I better end my “Notes” here? I believe I made a mistake in beginning to write them, anyway I have felt ashamed all the time I’ve been writing this story; so it’s hardly literature so much as a corrective punishment.  Why, to tell long stories, showing how I have spoiled my life through morally rotting in my corner, through lack of fitting environment, through divorce from real life, and rankling spite in my underground world, would certainly not be interesting; a novel needs a hero, and all the traits for an anti-hero are expressly gathered together here, and what matters most, it all produces an unpleasant impression, for we are...

Hope

To be human is to be a miracle of evolution conscious of its own miraculousness — a consciousness beautiful and bittersweet, for we have paid for it with a parallel awareness not only of our fundamental improbability but of our staggering fragility, of how physiologically precarious our survival is and how psychologically vulnerable our sanity. To make that awareness bearable, we have evolved a singular faculty that might just be the crowning miracle of our consciousness: hope.-- Erich Fromm


L'Enfant (The Child 2005)




The Dardenne Masterpiece

An unflinching look at the collision between survival and morality in industrial Belgium. 

"L'Enfant," which won the Golden Palm at Cannes 2005, is the film by the Dardenne brothers, Jean-Pierre and Luc, whose "The Son" (2002) made such an impact; audiences were moved in a deep, rare way. The Dardennes do not make morality tales. Their character Bruno is not aware that what he does is good or bad. He is unformed. There is a scene where he and Sonia tussle playfully in a car and then romp outside in a park like a couple of kids. Does he love her? Love is outside his emotional range. He takes money, spends it, doesn't even cultivate the persona of a hustler. He is that most terrifying kind of human being, the one who doesn't feel ordinary emotions or even understand that other people do.

We talk about the "point of view" of a film. "L'Enfant" sees with the eye of God. The film has granted free will to its central character, Bruno, and now it watches, intense but detached, to see how he will use it. Bruno is so amoral, he doesn't register the meaning of his actions. At first, his behavior is evil. He attempts repairs. Whether he is redeemed is a good question. At the end, he is weeping, but he cannot weep forever, and he has a limited idea of how to survive and make a living.

But let me just bluntly tell you what happens in the film, while observing that "L'Enfant," more than almost any film I can think of, is not about plot development but about putting one foot in front of the other. We meet Sonia and Bruno. She has just borne his child. The baby in her arms, she finds Bruno begging from cars at a traffic light while serving as a lookout for a burglary in progress. She shows him their child. He is as interested as if she had shown him her new phone card.

Sonia (Deborah Francois) looks in her late teens. Bruno (Jeremie Renier) looks older, yet in no way seems an adult, and indeed his criminal pals are all kids of around 14. He lives entirely in the moment. While Sonia was in the hospital, he sublet her apartment. When he divides loot from a robbery, he spends his share immediately. He buys a used perambulator because Sonia wants one. He rents an expensive convertible because he wants one. There will always be more money. Working? Working is for losers.




In a cafe, he meets a woman he does business with. He mentions the baby. She tells him, "People pay to adopt." Promising Sonia to watch the baby for an afternoon, he arranges to sell the child.

The Dardennes achieve their effects through an intense visual focus. They follow their characters as if their camera can look nowhere else. In "L'Enfant," their gaze is upon Bruno. They deliberately do not establish the newborn child as a character. Unlike the equally powerful "Tsotsi," their film doesn't show Bruno caring for the child. The child is simply something he carries, like loot or a video game. The movie also avoids the opportunity to develop Sonia, except as her behavior responds to Bruno's. When she lets out a cry of grief and faints, this is not so much what she does as what Bruno sees her do.
The greatness of the Dardennes is that they allow us to realize that these are questions and leave us free to try to answer them. What happens at the end of the film perhaps suggests grief and a desire to repent. I hope it does. But "L'Enfant" is not so simple as to believe that for Bruno there can be a happy ending. Here is a film where God does not intervene and the directors do not mistake themselves for God. It makes the solutions at the ends of other pictures seem like child's play.





    1. Release date: March 24, 2006 (USA)
      Language: French
      Budget: 3.6 million EUR







"We try to film the flow of life... the resistance of the world." — Luc Dardenne

Essential Filmography


FilmKey FocusCinematic Impact
La Promesse (1996)A teenager is torn between loyalty to his father and a promise made to a dying, undocumented immigrant.Their major international breakthrough; established their raw, handheld aesthetic.
Rosetta (1999)A fierce young woman fights tooth and nail to secure a basic, dignity-restoring job.Won the Palme d'Or and directly inspired real-world labor reform in Belgium.
Le Fils (The Son) (2002)A grieving carpentry instructor is asked to apprentice the troubled teenager who, years earlier, unknowingly killed his young son.Widely considered their masterwork of moral suspense. Olivier Gourmet won Best Actor at Cannes for his incredibly restrained performance.
L'Enfant (The Child) (2005)A reckless young street hustler sells his newborn baby on the black market, then desperately tries to undo it.A devastating redemption story that earned them their second Palme d'Or.
Two Days, One Night (2014)A depressed factory worker has one weekend to convince her co-workers to forego their bonuses so she can keep her job.Proved they could seamlessly blend a major star (Marion Cotillard) into their gritty, naturalistic world.



The son (Le fils 2002) >>>






The Core Conflict: Jimmy and Bruno

The title L'Enfant operates on a brilliant dual meaning. Nominally, it refers to Jimmy, the newborn son of 20-year-old Sonia (Déborah François) and 19-year-old Bruno (Jérémie Renier). However, the true "child" of the film is Bruno himself.

Bruno lives entirely in the immediate present. He has no bank account, no permanent address, and survives on a rotating ecosystem of petty theft, panhandling, and managing a small crew of younger street kids. He views money not as capital or security, but as an immediate, fleeting instrument for play—buying leather jackets, renting convertibles, and treating life as a game.

When Sonia returns from the hospital with Jimmy, Bruno is entirely unequipped for the existential shift of fatherhood. Seeing the infant not as a human being but as an asset, Bruno makes a transactional choice that sets the film's frantic second half into motion: he sells his own son on the black market for quick cash.





Form and Aesthetic: The Dardenne Grammar

The Dardennes reject the stylistic flourishes of mainstream cinema to construct an unvarnished, immersive reality. Their signature approach includes:

  • The Restless Handheld Camera: The camera stays locked to the back of Bruno's neck or tracks his frantic movements at eye level. This creates a claustrophobic, kinetic energy, pulling the viewer into his chaotic survival mechanics.

  • Absence of Non-Diegetic Score: There is no musical soundtrack to cue emotional responses or romanticize the poverty. The audio landscape is composed entirely of passing cars, cold wind, scraping boots, and heavy breathing.

  • The Geography of Modernity: The film unfolds across cold concrete, underpasses, muddy riverbanks, and transitional spaces. It highlights a marginalized underclass existing parallel to, but completely excluded from, modern European prosperity.





Social Realism

The film is noted for its "unvarnished" look. There is no non-diegetic music (soundtrack), and the camera often follows the characters closely with handheld shots, creating a documentary-like intensity.




Critical Reception

  • Cannes Film Festival: Winner of the Palme d'Or.

  •  In 2017, The New York Times named it the 14th best film of the 21st century so far.

'Enfant remains a landmark of 21st-century realism. By refusing to sentimentalize or demonize its characters, the Dardenne brothers craft a profoundly empathetic portrait of youth on the edge. It does not offer easy answers to the systemic cycles of poverty and emotional neglect, but it insists on the possibility of human redemption. It is a quiet, intense masterpiece that lingers long after the screen fades to black.


Rosetta (1999)


At night before she goes to sleep, Rosetta has this conversation with herself: “Your name is Rosetta. My name is Rosetta. You found a job. I found a job. You’ve got a friend. I’ve got a friend. You have a normal life. I have a normal life. You won’t fall in a rut. I won’t fall in a rut. Good night. Good night.” This is a young woman determined to find a job at all costs. She is escaping from the world of her alcoholic mother, a tramp who lives in a ramshackle trailer and runs away near the beginning of the story, leaving her daughter to fend for herself. Rosetta sees an abyss yawning beneath her and will go to any lengths to avoid it.

Her story is told in a film that astonishingly won the Palme d’Or at the 1999 Cannes Film Festival, as well as the best actress prize for its star, Emilie Dequenne. The wins were surprising not because this is a bad film (in its uncompromising way, it’s a very good one) but because films like this–neorealist, without pedigree, downbeat, stylistically straightforward–do not often win at Cannes. Variety’s grudgingly positive review categorized it as “an extremely small European art movie from Belgium.” Not just European but Belgian.

“Rosetta” opens with its heroine being fired, unjustly, we think, from a job. She smacks the boss, is chased by the police, returns home to her mother’s trailer, and we get glimpses of her life as she sells old clothes for money and sometimes buries things like a squirrel. She fishes in a filthy nearby stream–for food, not fun. She makes a friend of Riquet (Fabrizio Rongione), a kid about her age who has a job in a portable waffle stand (yes, Belgian waffles in a Belgian art movie). He likes her, is kind to her, and perhaps she likes him.



One vignette follows another. We discover that unlike almost every teenage girl in the world, she can’t dance. That she has stomach pains, maybe from an ulcer. One day Riquet falls in the river while trying to retrieve her fishing line, and she waits a strangely long time before helping him to get out. Later she confesses she didn’t want him out. If he had drowned, she could have gotten his job. After all, the local waffle king likes her, and she’d have had a job already, had it not gone to his idiot son.

What happens next, I will leave for you to discover. The film has an odd subterranean power. It doesn’t strive for our sympathy or make any effort to portray Rosetta as colorful, winning or sympathetic. It’s a film of economic determinism, the story of a young woman for whom employment equals happiness. Or so she thinks until she has employment and is no happier, perhaps because that is something she has simply never learned to be.

https://www.rogerebert.com/reviews/rosetta-2000


MORE ABOUT FILM 




The Kinetic Camera

The film's energy is entirely dictated by its cinematography. Shot by Alain Marcoen, the camera doesn't merely observe Rosetta (played with a fierce, animalistic intensity by Émilie Dequenne in her debut); it chases her.

  • The Bodily Frame: The camera tracks right behind her shoulder or tightly handles her profile, pulling the audience directly into her frantic, physical rhythm as she sprints through muddy trailer parks, changes out of her boots in the woods, or scrambles for a factory floor position.

  • Absence of Score: There is no non-diegetic music to manipulate your feelings. The soundtrack is entirely environmental—the harsh clatter of machinery, gasping breaths, and the roar of passing traffic.

A Different Kind of Protagonist

Unlike traditional cinematic narratives of the disenfranchised, Rosetta isn't looking to overthrow a system or looking for pity. Her dream is radically, heartbreakingly modest: she just wants a "normal" life, which to her means a steady job and a slot in the economic machine.

"Your name is Rosetta. My name is Rosetta. You found a job. I found a job. You have a friend. I have a friend. You have a normal life. I have a normal life. You won't fall into the pit. I won't fall into the pit." 

This obsession makes her both a tragic figure and a deeply complicated moral agent. Her desperation strips away any room for sentimentality, leading her to make choices driven purely by the baseline need to survive.

The "Rosetta Law"

Rarely does a piece of fiction exert a immediate, tangible effect on state legislation, but Rosetta did. Deeply moved by the film's depiction of youth exploitation and the psychological toll of precarious labor, the Belgian government passed the Rosetta Plan (or Loi Rosetta) in 2000. The law legally prohibited employers from paying workers under the age of 25 less than the national minimum wage and mandated real training initiatives for young hires.